Skip to main content
MarketVault
BrowseExpertsTopicsTimelineMapSubmit

Disclaimer: MarketVault is an educational video curation platform. Nothing on this site constitutes financial advice, investment advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any asset. Always consult a qualified, regulated financial advisor before making investment decisions. Investing carries risk — you may lose money.

MarketVault

Curated financial insights from the world's top experts. Invest in your knowledge.

BrowseExpertsTopicsDecadesSubmit a ClipAboutContactEditorial PolicyArticles

© 2026 MarketVault. All footage remains the property of its original creators.

Privacy PolicyTerms of UseSupport

Developed with love as a personal project by Jamie McDonnell

ui-ux-design.comai-consultancy.company
PreviousUse arrow keysNext
0 views
Share this clip

Index Funds Win By a Landslide—Here's What I Learned

Tool ReviewDebateStrategy GuideBeginner Tutorialyoutube

I put $100,000 into an index fund, individual stocks, and real estate for 10 years to settle the index funds vs stocks vs real estate debate — and it's not close. Index funds win by a landslide, and it's not the winner most finance channels celebrate. This is index fund investing put head-to-head against two of the most popular alternatives people reach for once they cross six figures: picking individual stocks themselves, and buying real estate with a 20% down payment. Same starting amount, same 10 years, real historical return data for all three — a real estate vs stocks vs index fund comparison with the actual dollar figures, not just theory. The index fund result: a broad index fund tracking something like the S&P 500 has historically returned around 8% a year on a conservative real-return basis, for a fee that's often a few hundredths of a percent. Compare that to a typical actively managed fund charging around 1% — on $100,000 that's roughly $1,000 a year in fees versus about $30, and over 10 years that fee gap alone quietly costs $10,000-$15,000, for a fund that on average doesn't even beat the index it's trying to outperform. Then there's stock picking. Studies on actively managed funds — run by professionals with research teams and decades of experience — show that roughly 85-90% of them fail to beat a plain index fund over a 15-year stretch. Individual retail investors picking their own stocks tend to do worse than that, and it's rarely about skill. It's behavior: buying after a stock has already run up, selling after it's already dropped. One well-documented case: a legendary mutual fund that averaged 29% a year under its star manager, while the average investor in that same fund only walked away with about 7% a year — same fund, same manager, a fraction of the return, purely from bad timing. Real estate looks different because you're using the bank's leverage — $100,000 down at 20% controls a $500,000 property. That leverage can accelerate returns if

Added 21 Jul 2026



Know someone who'd love this clip?

Share it with friends and fellow fans.

Share this clip

Keep Exploring

All ExpertsAll TopicsAll DecadesBrowse by Format